I Need Your Opinions - My Front Porch

Which version is your favorite here? The first one is how it is now. I played around in photoshop and came up with t he following possibilites. So, which one do you like best? I put up a poll on the left side over there <--. And, if you don't mind sharing... why? Oh, and please only vote once. Or do you just plain think I'm nuts for thinking about painting at all? Click on the picture to see it bigger.
P.S. - Please ignore the unsightly hose, edging that I haven't put in yet, and the boys' balls. Welcome to my life!